Umpires' Approach to Holding the Ball Rule
Clarification on Ball Up Blowing
The AFL's Head of Officiating, Stephen McBurney, has emphasized that umpires will not blow their whistle for a ball up if the tackled player has an arm free to dispose of the ball. This approach aims to give players reasonable time to make a legal disposal, but it can also leave tacklers in a difficult position.
Interpreting Prior Opportunity
McBurney also clarifies the interpretation of the holding the ball rule. If a player has had prior opportunity to dispose of the ball, they must do so legally. However, when a player is tackled immediately, they must attempt to kick or handball. If the ball is pinned, a ball up will be called; if the ball is knocked out, play will continue.
Invidious Position for Tacklers
McBurney acknowledges that the current interpretation can put tacklers in an "invidious position," as they risk a free kick or a report if they take the player to ground dangerously. The AFL is monitoring this aspect of the rule to ensure that it is being adjudicated fairly.
Umpire Judgment and Blocking
McBurney explains that one of the most challenging aspects of officiating holding the ball is determining whether a disposal is legal when the umpire's view may be obstructed by other players. The addition of a fourth on-ground umpire has been implemented to minimize missed incorrect disposals.
Ongoing Communication and Dialogue
McBurney encourages coaches and football departments to provide specific examples of incidents that require clarification. The AFL is committed to maintaining open dialogue to ensure that the rule is being adjudicated consistently and fairly.